Digital Observatory


About NewsTalk

As of 13 November 2023

NewsTalk is an aggregator of reader commentary on the majority of Australian news sites. NewsTalk also harvests Reddit comment threads linking Australian news stories. This provides good coverage of the Australian news landscape even when publishers don’t support on-site reader comments.

Figure 1: Number of stories by source

Figure 2: Number of comments by source and comment type

Figure 3: Proportion of comments by source and comment type

Table 1: Number of comments by comment type
Comment type Number of comments Percentage of comments
Linked comment 593,947 37%
Site comment 1,032,568 63%
Total comments 1,626,515 100%

Figure 4: Distribution of number of comments by story

(a) Excluding stories with zero or a very large number (97.5 percentile) of site comments or linked comments

Table 2: Descriptive statistics for comment length (in words) by comment type
Statistic Linked comments Site comments
Average comment length 42.7 39.6
Median comment length 26.0 25.0
Standard deviation of comment length 57.8 48.7
Skewness of comment length 6.2 4.4

Figure 5: Average comment length (in words) by source and comment type

Table 3: Average number of comments per story by comment type
Comment type Average number of comments per story
Site comment 32.4
Linked comment 18.6
Total comments 51.0
Table 4: Number of stories and comments by source
Source Number of stories Number of comments
Nine Media 7,051 500,736
MSN News 5,967 137,547
ABC News 3,798 247,414
Australian Community Media 2,403 14,173
The Guardian 2,314 374,302
Sky News Australia 2,043 145,795
Crikey 1,839 42,578
The New Daily 1,315 30,444
Kotaku AU 1,022 2,400
Echo Media 888 3,341
Perth Now 767 15,913
Independent Australia 763 14,005
The Conversation 617 35,895
iTnews 355 1,977
News.com.au 341 38,402
SBS News 240 16,119
MamaMia 91 397
The Saturday Paper 71 5,077
Table 5: Average and median number of comments by source and comment type
Source Comment type Average comments Median comments
ABC News Site comment 0.0 0.0
ABC News Linked comment 65.1 18.0
ABC News Total comments 65.1 18.0
Australian Community Media Site comment 5.8 3.0
Australian Community Media Linked comment 0.1 0.0
Australian Community Media Total comments 5.9 3.0
Crikey Site comment 18.3 10.0
Crikey Linked comment 4.9 0.0
Crikey Total comments 23.2 11.0
Echo Media Site comment 3.7 2.0
Echo Media Linked comment 0.0 0.0
Echo Media Total comments 3.8 2.0
Independent Australia Site comment 14.5 10.0
Independent Australia Linked comment 3.8 0.0
Independent Australia Total comments 18.4 10.0
Kotaku AU Site comment 2.3 1.0
Kotaku AU Linked comment 0.0 0.0
Kotaku AU Total comments 2.3 1.0
MSN News Site comment 17.6 6.0
MSN News Linked comment 5.5 0.0
MSN News Total comments 23.1 7.0
MamaMia Site comment 4.4 2.0
MamaMia Linked comment 0.0 0.0
MamaMia Total comments 4.4 2.0
News.com.au Site comment 0.0 0.0
News.com.au Linked comment 112.6 39.0
News.com.au Total comments 112.6 39.0
Nine Media Site comment 68.6 25.0
Nine Media Linked comment 2.5 0.0
Nine Media Total comments 71.0 26.0
Perth Now Site comment 19.1 12.0
Perth Now Linked comment 1.6 0.0
Perth Now Total comments 20.7 12.0
SBS News Site comment 0.0 0.0
SBS News Linked comment 67.2 11.5
SBS News Total comments 67.2 11.5
Sky News Australia Site comment 69.4 29.0
Sky News Australia Linked comment 2.0 0.0
Sky News Australia Total comments 71.4 29.0
The Conversation Site comment 5.7 0.0
The Conversation Linked comment 52.5 3.0
The Conversation Total comments 58.2 12.0
The Guardian Site comment 83.7 0.0
The Guardian Linked comment 78.1 16.0
The Guardian Total comments 161.8 70.0
The New Daily Site comment 18.7 5.0
The New Daily Linked comment 4.5 0.0
The New Daily Total comments 23.2 6.0
The Saturday Paper Site comment 0.0 0.0
The Saturday Paper Linked comment 71.5 18.0
The Saturday Paper Total comments 71.5 18.0
iTnews Site comment 4.2 2.0
iTnews Linked comment 1.4 0.0
iTnews Total comments 5.6 2.0

Contact information

Digital Observatory
Research Infrastructure | QUT
digitalobservatory.net.au/qut-digital-observatory
digitalobservatory@qut.edu.au
@ObservatoryTeam
Ph: +61 7 3138 6849